Can Domestic Violence Include Economic Deprivation?

    Family Law Guides
Law4u App Download

Yes, economic deprivation is recognized as a form of domestic violence in many legal systems, including under international conventions and national laws. It involves the use of financial control to coerce, manipulate, or dominate an intimate partner. Economic abuse often leaves the victim without the resources needed to leave the abusive situation, effectively trapping them in a cycle of dependency. While physical abuse is often more immediately visible, economic deprivation can have equally damaging, long-term effects on the victim’s mental, emotional, and financial well-being.

1. What is Economic Deprivation or Financial Abuse?

Economic abuse refers to behaviors that undermine a person’s ability to maintain financial independence, often to the point where the victim becomes financially dependent on the abuser. This is a subtle but powerful form of control that may not leave physical scars but can have a profound psychological impact. Common forms of economic deprivation include:

  • Controlling all financial resources: One partner may prevent the other from accessing or controlling the family’s finances, such as bank accounts, income, or even basic financial decisions.
  • Withholding money: The abuser may give the victim an insufficient allowance, restrict access to shared bank accounts, or make all purchasing decisions, leaving the victim unable to afford necessities.
  • Forcing economic dependence: In some cases, the abuser may actively limit the victim's ability to work or pursue an education, sometimes forbidding them to hold a job or access transportation, making the victim entirely dependent on the abuser financially.
  • Building debt in the victim's name: An abuser may open credit accounts or take out loans in the victim's name, creating financial ruin for them.
  • Sabotaging career opportunities: The abuser may discourage or prevent the victim from seeking career advancement, educational opportunities, or networking, effectively trapping them in a cycle of financial dependency.
  • Refusing to contribute to household expenses: One partner may refuse to contribute to bills, rent, or daily expenses, forcing the other partner to bear the financial burden alone.

2. How Courts and Laws View Economic Deprivation as Domestic Violence:

Many legal systems now recognize that domestic violence extends beyond just physical or sexual abuse and includes psychological, emotional, and financial abuse. In some countries, economic deprivation is specifically listed as a form of domestic violence under civil protection orders or domestic abuse laws.

United Nations Declaration:

The United Nations Declaration on the Elimination of Violence against Women (1993) recognizes economic abuse as a form of violence, defining it as controlling or restricting access to resources, such as money, housing, or employment, to harm or control a person.

National Laws:

In many countries, domestic violence laws now include provisions for economic abuse. For example, in India, Section 12 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act (2005) includes economic abuse as a form of domestic violence, granting women the right to seek compensation for the economic losses they suffer due to such abuse.

United States:

Several states have updated their domestic violence statutes to include economic control. For instance, the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) in the U.S. covers financial abuse as a form of coercive control and allows victims to seek legal protection.

United Kingdom:

In the UK, economic abuse is considered a form of coercive control under the Serious Crime Act 2015. The law specifically includes the withholding of money and economic dependency as forms of abuse.

3. Legal Remedies for Victims of Economic Deprivation:

Victims of economic abuse have several legal remedies to help them regain financial independence and break free from the cycle of abuse:

Domestic Violence Protection Orders (DVPO):

In many countries, victims of domestic violence can apply for protection orders that may include provisions for financial support, access to bank accounts, or maintenance payments to ensure they are not left without means of support.

Alimony or Spousal Support:

In cases of divorce or separation, victims of economic deprivation may be entitled to spousal support (also called alimony), especially if they have been kept financially dependent on the abuser during the relationship.

Property and Asset Division:

In divorce proceedings, courts will consider the financial abuse and may award a larger portion of marital assets or property division to the victim of economic abuse.

Legal Aid:

Victims of economic abuse often lack the financial resources to seek help, but legal aid programs may provide free or reduced-cost legal services to assist in obtaining protection orders or seeking financial compensation.

Child Support:

If the victim has children, they may be entitled to child support payments to help ensure that they and their children can maintain financial stability.

4. How Economic Abuse Affects the Victim:

Economic deprivation can leave victims feeling powerless, worthless, and isolated. Financial dependency on the abuser can create fear, particularly if the abuser threatens to withdraw financial support or if the victim believes they have no way out of the abusive situation.

Emotional and Psychological Impact:

Economic deprivation can leave victims feeling powerless, worthless, and isolated. Financial dependency on the abuser can create fear, particularly if the abuser threatens to withdraw financial support or if the victim believes they have no way out of the abusive situation.

Social and Physical Consequences:

Victims may face social stigma, shame, and isolation due to their inability to leave the relationship. They may not have the resources to access shelters, legal help, or medical care. Moreover, the long-term financial instability caused by economic abuse can have lasting impacts on the victim's credit score, job prospects, and overall financial future.

Impact on Children:

When children are involved, economic abuse can affect their quality of life. It can prevent the victim from providing the children with basic needs, education, and opportunities, and it may also affect their emotional well-being as they witness the financial instability in the household.

5. Strategies to Protect Against Economic Deprivation:

Seek Legal Protection: Victims of financial abuse should consider seeking legal advice and protection orders to prevent the abuser from continuing to control their finances. A domestic violence attorney can help navigate the legal process and secure relief.

Financial Independence:

If possible, victims should try to regain financial independence by opening a separate bank account, seeking employment or education opportunities, or accessing financial assistance programs for abuse survivors.

Access Support Services:

Many domestic violence shelters and organizations offer financial counseling, job training programs, or emergency financial assistance to help victims of economic abuse rebuild their lives.

Example:

Sophia was married to Michael for 10 years. Throughout their marriage, Michael controlled all the finances, leaving Sophia with no access to bank accounts or money of her own. She was prohibited from working outside the home and forced to rely on Michael for even basic needs. When she tried to leave the marriage, Michael threatened to withhold money and took out loans in her name, leaving her financially trapped.

Sophia sought help from a domestic violence shelter, where she learned about her legal rights and financial protections. With the assistance of an attorney, Sophia was able to apply for a protection order that included access to financial accounts and maintenance payments. She also sought spousal support in the divorce proceedings, which helped her regain financial independence. Eventually, Sophia was able to rebuild her life, gain employment, and secure a stable future for herself and her children.

Conclusion:

Economic deprivation is a significant form of domestic violence that can have long-lasting effects on the victim’s mental, emotional, and financial health. Legal systems increasingly recognize financial abuse as a form of coercive control and provide remedies to help victims regain financial independence and legal protections. By seeking legal advice and utilizing support services, victims of economic deprivation can begin the process of healing and regain control over their lives.

Answer By Law4u Team

Family Law Guides Related Questions

Discover clear and detailed answers to common questions about Family Law Guides. Learn about procedures and more in straightforward language.

Get all the information you want in one app! Download Now