- 29-Apr-2025
- Personal Injury Law
With the rapid expansion of telemedicine in India, especially after the COVID-19 pandemic, the healthcare system has seen many innovations in delivering healthcare remotely. However, the rise in telemedicine services has also led to an increase in fraudulent practices. Telemedicine frauds can involve unethical actions like misrepresentation of credentials, unnecessary prescriptions, or incorrect diagnoses made during online consultations. Legally, telemedicine fraud in India is addressed through various regulatory frameworks, criminal laws, and medical ethics guidelines to ensure the protection of patients and the integrity of healthcare services.
The Telemedicine Practice Guidelines issued by the Medical Council of India (MCI) (now the National Medical Commission (NMC)) in 2020 provide a legal framework for telemedicine practices in India. These guidelines aim to ensure that telemedicine is practiced ethically and professionally.
These guidelines establish rules for conducting teleconsultations, ensuring patient confidentiality, appropriate diagnosis, and medication prescriptions. If telemedicine services deviate from these guidelines, the healthcare providers may be held accountable for fraud.
Example: A doctor providing an online consultation for a medical condition they are not qualified to treat, or giving prescriptions without a proper consultation, is committing fraud under these guidelines.
Telemedicine fraud can lead to criminal charges under the Indian Penal Code (IPC), particularly under sections dealing with cheating (Section 420), forgery (Section 465), and criminal breach of trust (Section 406).
Example: If a doctor engages in fraudulent billing practices or prescribes medications without a proper online consultation, they could face penalties under these sections, including fines or imprisonment.
The Information Technology Act, 2000 (IT Act) also plays a role in telemedicine frauds in India, especially when there are issues of data privacy or cyber fraud. If fraudsters hack into a patient's digital health record or engage in identity theft, they can face penalties under Section 66C (identity theft) and Section 66D (cheating by personation) of the IT Act.
Example: If a fraudster impersonates a licensed doctor and gives incorrect medical advice, they could face prosecution under the IT Act for cyber fraud.
The National Medical Commission (NMC) and respective State Medical Councils regulate medical practices in India. They investigate complaints of unethical behavior by healthcare professionals practicing telemedicine, including fraudulent prescriptions or misdiagnosis.
Doctors who are found to be violating the telemedicine guidelines or engaging in fraudulent practices may face suspension, revocation of medical licenses, or disbarment from practicing medicine.
Example: A doctor who continues to prescribe medications for conditions they are not qualified to treat may have their license revoked by the NMC.
Under The Consumer Protection Act, 2019, patients who experience fraudulent telemedicine practices can file complaints against healthcare providers for deficiency in service. The Act allows patients to seek compensation for harm caused by fraudulent or substandard services.
Example: If a patient receives an incorrect diagnosis or a prescription that was not medically necessary via telemedicine, they can approach the Consumer Forum to file a complaint and seek compensation.
In case of cyber fraud, such as data breaches or fraudulent billing, cases can be investigated by cybercrime units under the Cyber Crime Investigation Cell (CCIC) of local police. This includes instances where personal health data is illegally accessed or altered, or when unauthorized individuals offer fraudulent telemedicine consultations.
Example: If a healthcare provider's online platform is hacked and patient data is stolen or misused, the incident will be investigated as a cybercrime under Indian cyber laws.
Regulatory bodies such as the NMC, along with healthcare associations, are focusing on educating healthcare providers and patients about telemedicine ethics, fraudulent practices, and the legal implications. This is done through awareness campaigns and trainings on secure telemedicine practices and informed consent.
Example: Healthcare providers are trained on how to verify patient identities and ensure that prescriptions are made based on legitimate consultations.
A person posing as a doctor conducts telemedicine consultations without a medical license and offers false diagnoses, leading to patients receiving inappropriate or harmful treatments.
Legal Action: The fraudster can be arrested under sections of the Indian Penal Code for cheating, impersonation, and forgery. They could also face charges under the IT Act for identity theft.
A doctor prescribes medications that are not required, without examining the patient, simply to increase prescription volume for financial benefits, or to boost sales for a pharmaceutical company.
Legal Action: The doctor could face disciplinary action by the NMC, including suspension of their medical license, as well as criminal charges for fraud and professional misconduct.
A telemedicine platform is hacked, leading to patient data being stolen or misused for fraudulent purposes, such as identity theft or fraudulent insurance claims.
Legal Action: Cybercrime authorities would investigate the breach under the IT Act, and the platform could be fined for non-compliance with data protection standards.
Telemedicine frauds in India are addressed through a combination of regulatory guidelines, criminal laws, and consumer protection measures. Laws such as the Indian Penal Code, the Information Technology Act, and the Consumer Protection Act provide frameworks to hold fraudulent healthcare providers accountable. The National Medical Commission (NMC) ensures ethical practice in telemedicine, while regulatory guidelines protect both patients and healthcare professionals from fraud. As telemedicine continues to grow in India, robust legal frameworks and continued vigilance will be essential to combat fraud and ensure patient safety in the digital health space.
Answer By Law4u Team
Discover clear and detailed answers to common questions about Healthcare and Medical Malpractice. Learn about procedures and more in straightforward language.
